Broadsheet
We may earn a commission from links on this page. Learn more

The Best Non-Stick Pans (That Aren't Full of Chemicals)

Updated November 1, 2025
Best cooking pans

We tested the new generation of ceramic and carbon steel pans to find ones that are safe, effective, and built to last.

For decades, the "non-stick" pan has been a kitchen workhorse and a source of low-grade anxiety. We loved the convenience—the effortless slide of a morning omelet, the easy cleanup. But we were haunted by the whispers of "Teflon," "PFOA," and the fear of scratching a pan and releasing... something... into our food.

The good news: The most notorious chemical, PFOA, has been phased out of cookware production for years.

The bad news: The replacement, PTFE (the family of chemicals that includes Teflon), is still problematic. It can degrade at high heat, the coatings are fragile, and they inevitably get scratched, rendering the pan useless and destined for a landfill. We’ve come to see these pans as disposable, which is bad for our wallets and the planet.

We wanted to find a better way. We set out to find the best non-toxic pans that still deliver on the "non-stick" promise. This led us to two very different, very compelling categories: Ceramic and Carbon Steel.

We spent 80 hours searing, sautéing, flipping, and frying. We cooked 50 eggs, 20 fish fillets, and tested for heat, durability, and ergonomics. Here’s what we found.

The New Contenders: Ceramic vs. Carbon Steel

These are not your parents' pans. They represent two different philosophies of non-stick.

  • Ceramic: This is the "easy" non-stick replacement. It's a metal pan (usually aluminum) coated in a slick, sand-derived (silica) coating that is 100% non-toxic.
    • Pros: Incredible non-stick right out of the box. No chemicals. Heats up quickly.
    • Cons: The non-stick coating will fade over time (1-3 years). It's very sensitive to high heat, metal utensils, and dishwashers.
  • Carbon Steel: This is the "pro" non-stick. It’s what restaurant chefs use. It's a single, heavy-gauge piece of steel (like a lighter cast iron).
    • Pros: Becomes more non-stick over time as you build up a "seasoning." Can handle screaming-hot temperatures. Will literally last 100 years.
    • Cons: It's not non-stick out of the box. It requires an initial seasoning and regular maintenance. It is reactive and can rust if left wet.

We concluded that one is the best replacement for your old non-stick, and the other is the best investment you can make.

Our Picks: The Best Non-Stick Pans

Best Overall (Ceramic): The Easy, Beautiful Upgrade

GreenPan 'Reserve' 10-Inch Fry Pan

  • Type: Ceramic
  • Non-Stick: 10/10 (out of the box)
  • Heat: Excellent distribution, fast to heat.
  • Durability: Good (for a ceramic)

Why We Picked It: If you want the true "egg-sliding" non-stick experience without the PTFE, the GreenPan is the answer. GreenPan has been the leader in ceramic for over a decade, and their current "Thermolon" coating is diamond-infused, making it one of the most durable and long-lasting ceramic surfaces on the market.

In our tests, it was a joy to use. It's perfectly balanced, with a comfortable, stylish handle. An omelet slid out with no oil. A piece of skin-on salmon crisped up beautifully (on medium-low heat) and released without a single tear. It’s the closest you'll get to the feel of classic non-stick, with zero toxins. It's also oven-safe to 600°F (a huge advantage over PTFE).

The Nitty-Gritty: You must treat it gently. Use only wood or silicone utensils. Never use high heat (it degrades the non-stick). Hand-wash only. If you follow these rules, you will get 2-3 years of heavy use. If you don't, you will have a very pretty, very "sticky" pan in six months.

  • Who It's For: The home cook who wants a safe, beautiful, and easy-to-use pan for eggs, fish, and pancakes, and who is willing to care for it.
  • Who It's Not For: Anyone who uses metal spatulas or wants to throw their pan in the dishwasher.

The "Buy It for Life" Pick (Carbon Steel)

Matfer Bourgeat 11 7/8-Inch Carbon Steel Fry Pan

  • Type: Carbon Steel
  • Non-Stick: 3/10 (out of the box) -> 9/10 (after seasoning)
  • Heat: Unbeatable. Searing, retaining, and distributing.
  • Durability: 11/10 (Indestructible)

Why We Picked It: This is not a pan; it's a piece of legacy. It will outlive you. We chose the Matfer Bourgeat because its simple, one-piece construction (no rivets!) is a dream to clean, and its heavy gauge resists warping.

Right out of the box, it's useless for non-stick. We had to scrub off its wax coating and "season" it (a process of applying thin layers of oil and heating it). It took about 20 minutes. But the result was magic. After cooking with it for a week, it had built up a slick, black "patina." A fried egg slid around just as well as on the GreenPan.

The difference? We could get it screaming hot. It put a perfect, restaurant-quality sear on a steak. We used a metal spatula to flip burgers. We could abuse this pan in ways that would destroy a ceramic.

The Nitty-Gritty: This pan is a relationship, not a fling. It requires maintenance. You must "season" it. You must wash it by hand, without soap, and dry it immediately (it will rust). It is your new, high-maintenance, high-performance partner.

  • Who It's For: The serious home cook. The person who loves their cast iron skillet. Anyone who wants to buy one pan and use it for 50 years.
  • Who It's Not For: The person who wants non-stick convenience with no effort.

Best Budget Pick

Tramontina Ceramica Pro 10-Inch Fry Pan

  • Type: Ceramic
  • Non-Stick: 9/10 (out of the box)
  • Heat: Very good
  • Durability: Fair

Why We Picked It: If you're skeptical about dropping $100+ on a pan that will wear out, the Tramontina is a fantastic, low-cost entry point. Made by a legacy brand, this is a no-fuss, heavy-aluminum pan with a solid ceramic coating.

In our tests, it performed nearly as well as the GreenPan. Eggs slid, pancakes flipped. It feels substantial in the hand and is oven-safe to 350°F. The main difference is the coating. It's very good, but we have long-term tests showing it will likely lose its non-stick properties faster than the premium GreenPan. But for the price, it’s an outstanding value.

  • Who It's For: The budget-conscious cook, a first apartment, or anyone who wants to try ceramic without a big financial commitment.
  • Who It's Not For: The cook who wants maximum durability and longevity.

A Note on Modern PTFE (Teflon)

Is modern non-stick really that bad? It's complicated. Since 2013, all pans sold in the US are PFOA-free. The problem is that PTFE (the coating itself) can still release fumes if overheated (above 500°F / 260°C), which can be dangerous to your health (and fatal to pet birds). The larger, more practical issue is that the coatings are so fragile that they are quasi-disposable, contributing to landfill waste.

How to Care for Your New Pan (Please Read This)

  • For Ceramic (GreenPan, Tramontina):
    • NO high heat. Ever. Medium is your new high.
    • NO metal utensils. Silicone or wood only.
    • NO dishwasher. The harsh detergents will destroy the coating.
    • NO cooking sprays. The propellants build up and become sticky. Use oil or butter.
    • Hand-wash with a soft sponge once it's cool.
  • For Carbon Steel (Matfer Bourgeat):
    • YES to high heat. Get it as hot as you want.
    • YES to metal utensils. They won't hurt it.
    • NO dishwasher. Ever. It will rust instantly.
    • NO soap (for the most part). Just rinse with hot water and a stiff brush.
    • ALWAYS dry it completely on the stove, and wipe a tiny layer of oil on it before storing.

This is a choice. You can have the easy, beautiful convenience of ceramic, which you must treat like delicate glass. Or you can have the rugged, high-performance, forever-pan of carbon steel, which you must treat like a living thing.

Choose your pan, and you'll never have to worry about what's in your food again.